545. Enough with the Slippery Slopes!

545.滑溜溜的斜坡已经够了!

Freakonomics Radio

社会与文化

2023-06-08

44 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

Gun control, abortion rights, drug legalization — it seems like every argument these days claims that if X happens, then Y will follow, and we’ll all be doomed to Z. Is the slippery-slope argument a valid logical construction or just a game of feelingsball?

单集文稿 ...

  • My name is Ben Gold.

  • I am a criminal defense attorney, and my practice is in military law.

  • Gold served as a surface warfare officer in the navy.

  • And after tours in the Persian Gulf, in Hawaii, he decided to go to law school.

  • He wanted to keep working with the military, but he didn't want to be a lawyer for the military.

  • I had seen some serious flaws in the military justice system, and I wasn't quite sure I wanted to be fully a part of it.

  • During law school, Gold learned to analyze legal arguments, and there was one type of argument that he kept coming across.

  • I think I heard a clip in some podcast or something of a politician who had said, you know, allowing for universal background checks, it's a slippery slope from there, because what prevents the government from then instituting entirely new and different surveillance programs?

  • Ah, yes, the slippery slope argument.

  • I thought to myself, well, there's a lot of things that would prevent that from happening.

  • For instance, a new law would have to be made.

  • There'd be legislation, there would be a new Supreme Court ruling.

  • That said, the slippery slope argument is pretty much everywhere these days, at least in the media and in politics.

  • If we make the ars, you have to register them or they're banned.

  • Then the next step is a handgun.

  • That's the slippery slope.

  • If we're just willing to cancel student loan debt, why can't we just cancel credit card debt, mortgage payments?

  • Again, it just leads to the slippery slope.

  • If we can't reach a point of integrity, honesty, and decency, we just slide down a slippery slope to chaos and fascism.

  • Have you ever wondered how the slope became so slippery?