While watching a movie, David notices a discrepancy. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
From Gimlet.
I'm Starly Kine, and this is Mystery Show.
Why is there you?
Every week I solve a new mystery.
Why is there me?
Mysteries that can't be solved.
Online mysteries you can't solve yourself.
Why does my mother kiss my father occasionally?
Up until now, there hasn't been anyone to help with this.
That person is now me.
Those mysteries.
Tomorrow I'll find out all I should know.
Those Mysteries.
This week's mystery belongs to David.
David is a former political cartoonist who runs an artisanal pencil sharpening company out of his home in the country.
You send him your unsharpened pencils and he sends them back to you, sharpened.
I'm telling you this so you'll understand that David is both a man who appreciates the more nuanced details of life and a man with a lot of time on his hands.
One afternoon David rang me up and said he had something pressing he needed to speak with me about.
I caught the 318 train up to his house and sat in the second car from the front in the window seat.
Upon my arrival, David greeted me warmly.